The Silkiest Icing You'll Ever Eat
Before you read any farther, let me start by writing this: Icing is by no means healthy. It is not nutritious, and it is not a food any of us should eat on a regular basis. It's sugar and butter, and not much more.
That said, boy is it delicious when I eat it on special occasions. For the boys' birthdays, holidays, and for bake sales at school, I make this icing. It's not a true buttercream, which includes eggs and a sugar syrup, but this one is easy and silky smooth.
If you're going to eat cake with icing, eat the real deal. Boxed cake mixes have come a long way, but canned frosting is full of trans fats, and artificial ingredients. They can't hold a candle to homemade versions.
What's the secret to great icing?
I learned from a wedding cake decorator years ago that the best way to make icing is in a food processor. Mixers incorporate too much air. By using the food processor your icing will be silky smooth. (You can use a mixer, but it won't be as smooth.)
Those who know me well will say that I am not a snob--except for when it comes to icing. I want the real stuff! To me cakes are ruined with fake whippy icings made with shortening.

Ever wonder why grocery store cakes use whippy icings? Cost! It is a lot cheaper to prepare whippy icings using emulsified shortenings than butter, but the taste is incomparable. Shortening-based icings will leave a greasy film in your mouth. Yuck!
For natural colored icing, use pureed and strained berries.
Get the recipe for my Silky Smooth White Icing.
This recipe makes 2 cups, which yields 32 one-tablespoon servings. That generous dollop of icing will set you back about 80 calories and just 3 g fat.
Are you a cake or an icing person? What's your favorite kind of cake? What about icing? Do you make your own?
That said, boy is it delicious when I eat it on special occasions. For the boys' birthdays, holidays, and for bake sales at school, I make this icing. It's not a true buttercream, which includes eggs and a sugar syrup, but this one is easy and silky smooth.
If you're going to eat cake with icing, eat the real deal. Boxed cake mixes have come a long way, but canned frosting is full of trans fats, and artificial ingredients. They can't hold a candle to homemade versions.
What's the secret to great icing?
I learned from a wedding cake decorator years ago that the best way to make icing is in a food processor. Mixers incorporate too much air. By using the food processor your icing will be silky smooth. (You can use a mixer, but it won't be as smooth.)
Those who know me well will say that I am not a snob--except for when it comes to icing. I want the real stuff! To me cakes are ruined with fake whippy icings made with shortening.

Ever wonder why grocery store cakes use whippy icings? Cost! It is a lot cheaper to prepare whippy icings using emulsified shortenings than butter, but the taste is incomparable. Shortening-based icings will leave a greasy film in your mouth. Yuck!
For natural colored icing, use pureed and strained berries.
Get the recipe for my Silky Smooth White Icing.
This recipe makes 2 cups, which yields 32 one-tablespoon servings. That generous dollop of icing will set you back about 80 calories and just 3 g fat.
Are you a cake or an icing person? What's your favorite kind of cake? What about icing? Do you make your own?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > Pantry Containers 101





















Comments
I have baked and decorated cakes for 35 years and made many different icings
I will try this one, sounds so good, a little ata atime - 5/2/2011 3:45:50 PM
I always make cakes from scratch. My favorite is an applesauce spice cake packed with raisins and walnuts. - 4/27/2011 8:51:55 PM
As far as cake or frosting? I love frosting - really good frosting that is. I prefer brownies (unfrosted) over cakes, but I'm not sure about whether I prefer brownies or frosting. I'll have to ponder that one.
- 4/26/2011 5:44:50 PM
I do make frosting very occasionally--NEVER buy it. In most cases I prefer cream cheese frosting--yum! - 4/26/2011 2:35:16 PM
That said, I am an icing person, only eat a wee bit of cake (or preferably, a cupcake) to go with the icing! - 4/26/2011 1:08:36 PM
Thanks for a new, oh-so-novice, cake decorator. :-) - 4/25/2011 6:27:13 PM
Funny, I was craving wedding/birthday cake yesterday (my treat day), but there was none to be found, and the single servings in the grocery store are just a yucky waste of my calorie budget.
Thanks for the recipe! - 4/25/2011 6:07:26 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›