Study: Parents' Diet Doesn't Influence Kids
I've always worked hard to set a good example for my kids when it comes to food choices. I try to make fruits and vegetables a staple in our diet and prepare meals that are generally healthy. But a new study says my hard work might not payoff, because kids aren't paying attention to the example their parents are setting.
A study in the journal Social Science and Medicine looked at a sample of adults and their children, ages 2 to 18. Researchers used questionnaires to track their eating habits and found little resemblance between the calorie and nutrient consumption of the parents and children.
Older children were the least likely to have a diet resembling their parents, which isn't surprising. The older kids get, the more they are influenced by peers, what they see on T.V. and other outside sources. The children's' diet did resemble their mothers more than fathers, but family income and parental education did not have an effect on the results.
I'd be interested to see a breakdown of these results by age group. I'm not surprised at the results for older children, but I would think the responses for younger children would be much different. My daughter is 2 and I basically control everything she eats, since she's a little young to cook for herself. I also think that if you show kids that food can be healthy but still taste good, they learn from that. Eventually she's going to have the freedom to decide if she wants a McDonald's Big Mac for dinner. My hope is that she'll know that it's OK to enjoy those kinds of things now and then if she wants them, but that normally she'd make healthier choices--and that's because of the example I will always set for her. Am I being overly optimistic?
So I'm a little skeptical about these results. What do you think? Do you feel like your example affects the food choices your children make?
A study in the journal Social Science and Medicine looked at a sample of adults and their children, ages 2 to 18. Researchers used questionnaires to track their eating habits and found little resemblance between the calorie and nutrient consumption of the parents and children.
Older children were the least likely to have a diet resembling their parents, which isn't surprising. The older kids get, the more they are influenced by peers, what they see on T.V. and other outside sources. The children's' diet did resemble their mothers more than fathers, but family income and parental education did not have an effect on the results.
I'd be interested to see a breakdown of these results by age group. I'm not surprised at the results for older children, but I would think the responses for younger children would be much different. My daughter is 2 and I basically control everything she eats, since she's a little young to cook for herself. I also think that if you show kids that food can be healthy but still taste good, they learn from that. Eventually she's going to have the freedom to decide if she wants a McDonald's Big Mac for dinner. My hope is that she'll know that it's OK to enjoy those kinds of things now and then if she wants them, but that normally she'd make healthier choices--and that's because of the example I will always set for her. Am I being overly optimistic?
So I'm a little skeptical about these results. What do you think? Do you feel like your example affects the food choices your children make?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > Habits of Fit People: Keep Fitness Equipment at Home























Comments
children who come in have overweight parents. Lifestyle seems to beget lifestyle...if
children grow up with parents who eat right and exercise;they seem to fall into the
same pattern. But you can't be nuts about it-there's room for treats in that healthy
lifestyle! - 2/22/2013 6:13:10 AM
but it makes me worry that when they could make the decision on their own they would take Mcdonald!! - 1/25/2011 2:44:13 PM
This was too extreme. When I left home & started taking care of myself, I went crazy on junk food & candy; chips were a valid supper choice; the answer to "I'm hungry" was that I could eat whatever I wanted. There was a year where I drank nothing but Diet Coke. This was also the year I came home from university with rickets from eating so poorly.
Now I'm aiming to be somewhere between where I grew up & when I first moved out. I weigh out my snack foods so I don't accidentally have chips for supper any more. If I have children, I want to teach them this in between approach to food, so they don't have that massive shock to the system when they can make their own food choices. - 12/1/2010 2:49:28 PM
Parents are too busy working. There are few stay at home moms preparing meals. Far too many parents in this day and age aren't eating healthy themselves and therefore the kids are learning the wrong way from the start. - 7/9/2010 7:58:33 AM
They will grow up, try different things and then realize junk food is junk food. Mine won't be perfect, nobody is, but they are smart enough to know what is good for their body and what isn't. We have to teach them and then like you said let them make choices in life. - 5/29/2010 12:04:25 PM
- 5/28/2010 9:00:47 AM
My son has asked can we have mcdonalds? I said no I have dinner already planned out and it will be ready in 20 minutes. Mind over matter. Either way he is hungry and wanting something now. So I try to out beat him on hunger and have something ready.
I am hungry when I get home also it works out pretty good. If dinner isn't ready yet I will cut up a apple for him and put in a bowl or carrots and give him a drink. It won't fill him all the way but it will calm the hunger.
I am hoping when he is on his own he will also use these ideas and skills so he can make good choices.
Thanks for the blog! - 4/21/2010 12:40:25 PM
My husband and I have 3 daughters between us who eat vastly different diets and whose fitness interests are also vastly different. I'm curious to see where their nutrition and fitness interests are when they make it into their 30s. - 3/23/2010 8:14:55 AM
2 children who until leaving home at 18 took their vitamins and ate little junk food. One went to college and within a semester had cavaties for the 1st time in her life!! Son went to Coast Guard , same effect. Those novacaine shots and the pain were such a shock they went back to a relatively healthy diet. - 3/22/2010 6:15:59 PM
Now that my daughter is in her 20's, I see that many of our eating habits that she did not seem to like when she was younger are now appearing in her own diet. For example, she did not like most vegetables, fruits, or home cooking when ages 10-18. She did eat what served between age 0-10, but it declined from there. She preferred what her friends had to eat. However, she just invited us over the other night to eat and the entire dinner could have been made by me or my sister or my mother! It was delicious mix of all fresh ingredients... none of which she would have used in her teens. - 2/18/2010 1:38:50 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›