Poll: Should Personal Trainers Be Licensed?
Earlier this week I had the opportunity to finally catch up on some of my reading. If you were to see my office, my shelves are lined with books covering all aspects of health and fitness, with running being my primary focus. But I also subscribe to many fitness publications including the American College of Sports Medicine Health and Fitness Journal.
In the March/April 2010 issue there was a very interesting article raising the question as to whether or not health/fitness and clinical exercise professionals should be licensed. And par for the course, this got me thinking.
I am not aware of any allied medical professional not required to be licensed by the state in which they practice. This goes for Registered Nurses, Licensed Vocational Nurses, Physical Therapists and Registered Dietitians just to name a few. Licensing is a safeguard for the community and for the profession. It requires the taking and passing of a comprehensive exam at the end of his/her studies. Once he/she receives his/ her license to practice, there is usually a yearly or bi-yearly re-licensing fee, along with proof of Continuing Education Units (CEUs) earned between the time of renewals. Not receiving the proper CEUs may lead to a revocation of one's license.
With so many of us turning to personal trainers to help us meet our fitness goals, how do we know if the qualifications our trainer received is appropriate for our needs? When we place our trust in those who will direct us on the proper path to reclaiming our health and fitness, it is important that we have full disclosure of their qualifications.
While many personal trainers are certified, certification is not the same as licensing. Certification just means the individual met the requirements of that particular program of study. That being said, some programs are more comprehensive than others and well exceed the educational standards for personal trainers, while other programs fall quite short in that area.
So why would licensing personal trainers, exercise physiologists and health fitness professionals be of benefit to us?
Licensing would require every individual to take a comprehensive exam at the end of his/her studies to guarantee a standardized qualification of knowledge is obtained regardless of where the individual received his/her education.
Currently the only state to license exercise physiologists is Louisiana. While other states have pursued passing legislation to do the same, so far that has yet to be seen and probably won't for some time. According to those is the industry, it does not appear that licensing will be a requirement any time soon, even though many believe there should be some type of competency exam, both written and practical, given at the end of their course of studies.
Not surprising, in a National Board of Fitness Examiners survey from 2006, of 2730 individuals who responded to the survey "76% agreed or strongly agreed that licensing of personal trainers will increase the perception of professionalism of personal trainers. While 75.4% feel that licensing of personal trainers will facilitate referrals from traditional health care providers, and 61% feel that insurance companies will be more likely to reimburse for services if personal trainers are licensed. 62.7% agree or strongly agree that they would like to be denoted as a licensed personal trainer".
Because licensing is not a current requirement for personal trainers, the next best suggestion is to check the personal trainer's credentials by asking the following questions or you can click on the following link to an article Coach Jen wrote on How to Choose a Personal Trainer.
For now, without any standards in the industry, it is even more imperative that you do your homework. Make sure the individual you are training with works in conjunction with you and the goals you want to meet.
And should your personal trainer begin to offer advice outside his/her area of expertise, such as specific nutrition or medical advice, this may be the time to rethink your situation. Offering standardized nutritional information such as eating a balanced diet of lean protein, healthy fats, fruits, veggies and whole grains, is well within their guidelines. But for a personal trainer to emphasize the taking of supplements or to recommend specific dietary advice which they are not authorized to do is outside their scope of knowledge, therefore, this may be a red flag to look elsewhere for your personal training advice.
Do you believe personal trainers should be licensed, if not why? Do you believe that by not having a standard in the industry makes it more difficult in choosing a trainer? What qualifications would be important to you when choosing a personal trainer?
In the March/April 2010 issue there was a very interesting article raising the question as to whether or not health/fitness and clinical exercise professionals should be licensed. And par for the course, this got me thinking.
I am not aware of any allied medical professional not required to be licensed by the state in which they practice. This goes for Registered Nurses, Licensed Vocational Nurses, Physical Therapists and Registered Dietitians just to name a few. Licensing is a safeguard for the community and for the profession. It requires the taking and passing of a comprehensive exam at the end of his/her studies. Once he/she receives his/ her license to practice, there is usually a yearly or bi-yearly re-licensing fee, along with proof of Continuing Education Units (CEUs) earned between the time of renewals. Not receiving the proper CEUs may lead to a revocation of one's license.
With so many of us turning to personal trainers to help us meet our fitness goals, how do we know if the qualifications our trainer received is appropriate for our needs? When we place our trust in those who will direct us on the proper path to reclaiming our health and fitness, it is important that we have full disclosure of their qualifications.
While many personal trainers are certified, certification is not the same as licensing. Certification just means the individual met the requirements of that particular program of study. That being said, some programs are more comprehensive than others and well exceed the educational standards for personal trainers, while other programs fall quite short in that area.
So why would licensing personal trainers, exercise physiologists and health fitness professionals be of benefit to us?
Licensing would require every individual to take a comprehensive exam at the end of his/her studies to guarantee a standardized qualification of knowledge is obtained regardless of where the individual received his/her education.
Currently the only state to license exercise physiologists is Louisiana. While other states have pursued passing legislation to do the same, so far that has yet to be seen and probably won't for some time. According to those is the industry, it does not appear that licensing will be a requirement any time soon, even though many believe there should be some type of competency exam, both written and practical, given at the end of their course of studies.
Not surprising, in a National Board of Fitness Examiners survey from 2006, of 2730 individuals who responded to the survey "76% agreed or strongly agreed that licensing of personal trainers will increase the perception of professionalism of personal trainers. While 75.4% feel that licensing of personal trainers will facilitate referrals from traditional health care providers, and 61% feel that insurance companies will be more likely to reimburse for services if personal trainers are licensed. 62.7% agree or strongly agree that they would like to be denoted as a licensed personal trainer".
Because licensing is not a current requirement for personal trainers, the next best suggestion is to check the personal trainer's credentials by asking the following questions or you can click on the following link to an article Coach Jen wrote on How to Choose a Personal Trainer.
- What is their educational background? Do they have a degree in exercise physiology or one of the allied health fields?
- Are they certified by a respected organization such as the American College of Sports Medicine, the American Council on Exercise or the National Academy of Sports Medicine? If not, where did they receive their certification?
- How long have they been a personal trainer? Where have they worked? What type of clients have they worked with?
- Do they keep current on the latest research? In other words, do they actively pursue continuing education opportunities?
For now, without any standards in the industry, it is even more imperative that you do your homework. Make sure the individual you are training with works in conjunction with you and the goals you want to meet.
And should your personal trainer begin to offer advice outside his/her area of expertise, such as specific nutrition or medical advice, this may be the time to rethink your situation. Offering standardized nutritional information such as eating a balanced diet of lean protein, healthy fats, fruits, veggies and whole grains, is well within their guidelines. But for a personal trainer to emphasize the taking of supplements or to recommend specific dietary advice which they are not authorized to do is outside their scope of knowledge, therefore, this may be a red flag to look elsewhere for your personal training advice.
Do you believe personal trainers should be licensed, if not why? Do you believe that by not having a standard in the industry makes it more difficult in choosing a trainer? What qualifications would be important to you when choosing a personal trainer?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > Best Member Blogs Week in Review










.jpg)


.jpg)









Comments
I know that if you don't know what you're doing, you could cause lots of injuries. Two of my friends have had torn muscles and stress fractures and I have plantar fasciitis because of poor training methods. Our bodies never "screamed" at us until it was too late. Damage can be caused by simply stretching at inappropriate times (when your muscles aren't warm...). I don't wish these preventable injuries on anybody and people who don't know should be protected from well meaning people who don't know either. - 7/3/2012 2:47:25 PM
As an aside, I'd like to state a correction that needs to be made to a statement in the post. It says that registered dietitians must be licensed in their state to practice, but this is not the case in some states. However, RDs are still required to sit for a national exam and take CEUs to maintain their registration. - 6/7/2010 7:47:57 PM
Sometimes professional groups voluntarily establish membership societies with professional standards and certification tests. Examples include Project Management Professionals (PMP) and Lactation Consultants. I am not sure to what extent these work. Maybe they do.
The Federal Government operates a couple of data banks (funded by user fees) to protect the public by keeping track of disciplinary actions taken against physicians, nurses, and certain allied health professionals, but it's not a panacea. Compliance with reporting requirements for certain disciplinary actions is pretty spotty. Some States (like Texas) make information on disciplinary actions against physicians freely available on the Internet. Others consider it a violation of privacy. Think about this: disciplined physicians can protect themselves in some cases by just moving across State lines. A few years ago, I was looking for a pediatric sub-specialist in Maryland for one of my kids. My insurance company gave me three names. In just a few minutes, I searched them all on the web. One had had his license revoked the previous year in Texas, one wasn't accepting any new BCBS patients, and the third had earned his medical degree in the 1950's. So much for choices.
In our current system, it's ultimately up to consumers to decide whether the services they are purchasing meet their standards. - 5/25/2010 10:54:50 PM
Licensure is a legislative action. The state legislature creates a bill that provides for licensing of a professions. The legislation may/may not “protect” a scope of practice. If the scope of practice is not protected then you may have a situation where professionals may practiced as licensed or unlicensed professionals.
Some state licensing bills and boards require little to no continuing education. In contrast, almost all certifying agencies require CEUs. This is because a certifying agency is certifying the competency of the certificate holder while the certificate is active. In my opinion, the blog doesn’t give suitable credence to certification. Many licensed processionals maintain professional certifications.
Registries are also an important credential for healthcare professionals. Registries usually require comprehensive exams (sometimes with experience requirements) which create a group of competent professionals. Most registries are run by professional organizations and are often seen a step toward licensure. Separate of licensure, registries are typically a good sign of competence. Many state legislatures use registries as their requirement for application for licensure. This is the case with RNs. For example if i ever have an ultrasound, i make sure the person performing the exam is a registered ultrasonographer.
A problem with using certification as the sole credential for exercise professionals is that the public is unaware of credible certifications. In addition there are more untrustworthy certifications for exercise professionals than credible certifications. I personally would recommend that people seek a personal trainer with a minimum of a bachelor’s degree in an allied health field if they are ignorant of the most credible certifications available. This of course isn’t fail proof.
I believe the Louisiana legislature used the American College of Sports Medicine’s Exercise Specialist Certification for their licensure requirement. I hold this certification and would have to say that it is not the appropriate level certification for a personal trainer.
After struggling with this topic for decades, I have now come to believe that personal trainers should be licensed.
- 5/25/2010 7:17:17 PM
But a license doesn't really make a trainer good, just as a Master's degree doesn't guarantee one is an excellent teacher. - 5/24/2010 9:18:41 PM
Do you believe that by not having a standard in the industry makes it more difficult in choosing a trainer? I am not comfortable paying a trainer to teach me what I can learn in a book. Call me a snob, but I would rather work with a licensed professional who is required to meet continuing education requirements, and who can teach me the latest and greatest (and safest) techniques. - 5/24/2010 1:51:19 PM
Licensure should be voluntary.
By making it voluntary, you would see who is truly dedicated to their profession. If licensure is voluntary, I believe licensed trainers would attract more customers, and probably, higher fees.
If that happens, well, any edge in business is profitable.
Capitalism by any other name is what our country has been founded on. - 5/24/2010 12:51:30 PM
Now personally if I am hiring someone rather than just dropping in on a class during travels, I'm going to select someone who is a member in good standing of their professional organization, has a good track record, has up to date credentials, and a reasonable certification :) And I know I will pay more for this level of expertise. - 5/24/2010 11:47:08 AM
If licensing personal trainers will prevent more injuries than I'm all for it. I have an acquaintance who was bed-ridden for nearly two weeks with a back injury after one session with a personal trainer. Not good. - 5/24/2010 10:57:30 AM
I am not a personal trainer, but I am a certified group fitness instructor. Where I work, we are required to carry personal liability insurance. The waivers you sign at the gym only protect the gym from being sued, not the instructor. So, even though many injuries are caused by people not listening to their bodies and pushing themselves beyond a safe limit, instructors still get sued by people not willing to take responsibility for their own actions.
I personally feel that certification is enough. Liscensing isn't going to stop incompetant people from practicing in the field; trust me. Be smart, listen to your body, and do what you feel comfortable and safe doing. - 5/24/2010 7:40:11 AM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›