Poll: Do People Really Understand the Mental Hardships of Being Overweight?
For the past year I have had the pleasure of reconnecting with some of my former classmates of 1980. Once a month we come together to sit down and catch up. We talk about old times, our families, jobs and everything in between. We can literally spend hours lost in conversation, laughter and sometimes tears. These great women, many of whom I knew in name only back in the day, have become such a wonderful network of support and encouragement for me.
Having spent most of my life, age 12 to 43, struggling with my weight, I never felt at peace with my body until the past 4 years. High school was a rough time for me. I was always heavier than many of the girls in my class and because of that I never felt like I fit in. I felt like a misfit. Much of that had to do with a lack of self-esteem on my part. I started my first diet when I was 12 and continued off and on until age 43. It’s a legacy I am not proud of, but one that has allowed me to get me to where I am today.
Many of these ladies never had a weight issue in high school so they could not understand, and rightfully so, the isolation of those of us who did. Thirty years later I can see the wisdom that my weight does not define who I am, but at age 15, 16 even 18 it was totally what defined me or what I thought at that time.
So this brings me to my question—Can those who have never struggled with their weight understand the plight of those of us who have?
Don’t get me wrong, I understand we all have struggles, but five years ago when I was forced to reflect on my own life I felt as though I was facing a mountain so high it was hard to see the summit from where I was standing. How could someone who only needed to lose 10 pounds or less relate to me who had to lose 80? How could they understand the emotional baggage of having to shop for an extra large size or larger? How could they understand the fear of being judged every time you went out to eat? Having others peer in your cart at the grocery store to see what you are buying? How could they understand the physical pain in your joints because of carrying the excess weight? The pure fatigue of doing just the simple things in life?
I once had a thin friend tell me years ago to just quit eating and the weight would come off. As simple as that seemed, that is precisely what I had been doing for 30 plus years and it only was making me fatter. She had little patience and more importantly little understanding and compassion.
However, when I started my journey I discovered that my weight issue was more involved than just eating fewer calories and getting in more exercise. While they are both very important and essential to our health, I had to walk the painful gauntlet of why I was using food to suppress my emotions. I was, and still am, to some degree an emotional eater. Food was the first thing I turned to when everything in my life began to spiral out of control. Food became my friend, confidant and comforter. It never judged me and it made me feel good--that was until guilt reared its ugly head. The minute the guilt kicked in was the minute I vowed I would start again the next day only to fail less than an hour into that day. I allowed my perfection to stand in my way of my success.
This journey we are on is one of self-discovery. One I like to call, “the why we do, what we do, when we do it” journey. In all the many years I spent dieting, the one area I failed to master was connecting my emotions to my eating. In other words, I had to stop and ask am I eating out of hunger or to suppress feeling the true emotions in my life.
My friend and I could never see the world in the same way. She believed if only I was better disciplined I could drop the weight. Sadly our friendship drifted apart and we both went our separate ways. That was a little over 7 years ago.
A few months ago I ran into her at my local mall and she was shocked to see how much weight I had lost and to hear that I was running. She was very complementary; however she appeared somewhat uncomfortable since she had put on some weight since we last saw one another and I could tell she wanted to get on her way. We said our good-byes and shared a hug and went about our day, but I was a little saddened that she felt the need to explain to me why she had put on the weight. Unfortunately, this is the most difficult aspect of the journey--and that is not judging ourselves like we feel others judge us. We should never feel as though we owe anyone an explanation unless we believe it will change the path we are on. So while many people may not be able to relate to our plight of having to lose 20, 40, 80, even a hundred pounds or more, our goal is not to change them but to change us.
Do you feel others judge you before they really get to know you? Do you believe those who have never had to deal with weight issues can relate to those of us who have?
Having spent most of my life, age 12 to 43, struggling with my weight, I never felt at peace with my body until the past 4 years. High school was a rough time for me. I was always heavier than many of the girls in my class and because of that I never felt like I fit in. I felt like a misfit. Much of that had to do with a lack of self-esteem on my part. I started my first diet when I was 12 and continued off and on until age 43. It’s a legacy I am not proud of, but one that has allowed me to get me to where I am today.
Many of these ladies never had a weight issue in high school so they could not understand, and rightfully so, the isolation of those of us who did. Thirty years later I can see the wisdom that my weight does not define who I am, but at age 15, 16 even 18 it was totally what defined me or what I thought at that time.
So this brings me to my question—Can those who have never struggled with their weight understand the plight of those of us who have?
Don’t get me wrong, I understand we all have struggles, but five years ago when I was forced to reflect on my own life I felt as though I was facing a mountain so high it was hard to see the summit from where I was standing. How could someone who only needed to lose 10 pounds or less relate to me who had to lose 80? How could they understand the emotional baggage of having to shop for an extra large size or larger? How could they understand the fear of being judged every time you went out to eat? Having others peer in your cart at the grocery store to see what you are buying? How could they understand the physical pain in your joints because of carrying the excess weight? The pure fatigue of doing just the simple things in life?
I once had a thin friend tell me years ago to just quit eating and the weight would come off. As simple as that seemed, that is precisely what I had been doing for 30 plus years and it only was making me fatter. She had little patience and more importantly little understanding and compassion.
However, when I started my journey I discovered that my weight issue was more involved than just eating fewer calories and getting in more exercise. While they are both very important and essential to our health, I had to walk the painful gauntlet of why I was using food to suppress my emotions. I was, and still am, to some degree an emotional eater. Food was the first thing I turned to when everything in my life began to spiral out of control. Food became my friend, confidant and comforter. It never judged me and it made me feel good--that was until guilt reared its ugly head. The minute the guilt kicked in was the minute I vowed I would start again the next day only to fail less than an hour into that day. I allowed my perfection to stand in my way of my success.
This journey we are on is one of self-discovery. One I like to call, “the why we do, what we do, when we do it” journey. In all the many years I spent dieting, the one area I failed to master was connecting my emotions to my eating. In other words, I had to stop and ask am I eating out of hunger or to suppress feeling the true emotions in my life.
My friend and I could never see the world in the same way. She believed if only I was better disciplined I could drop the weight. Sadly our friendship drifted apart and we both went our separate ways. That was a little over 7 years ago.
A few months ago I ran into her at my local mall and she was shocked to see how much weight I had lost and to hear that I was running. She was very complementary; however she appeared somewhat uncomfortable since she had put on some weight since we last saw one another and I could tell she wanted to get on her way. We said our good-byes and shared a hug and went about our day, but I was a little saddened that she felt the need to explain to me why she had put on the weight. Unfortunately, this is the most difficult aspect of the journey--and that is not judging ourselves like we feel others judge us. We should never feel as though we owe anyone an explanation unless we believe it will change the path we are on. So while many people may not be able to relate to our plight of having to lose 20, 40, 80, even a hundred pounds or more, our goal is not to change them but to change us.
Do you feel others judge you before they really get to know you? Do you believe those who have never had to deal with weight issues can relate to those of us who have?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > Ten New Best Member Blogs























Comments
Yes, I have never really struggled with my weight.
Yes, I am not always happy with my weight but I know that others would kill to be my size.
All my friends have weight problems, my husband struggled with weight issues for years and so does my daughter.
I understand and sometimes I feel like I am the same size as they are.
However, I look in the mirror and I know that I am not.
I have the same pain and suffering but I can't share that with someone over weight because they are dealing with their own issues.
How do you think the "skinny" person feels when we fight the same demons.
I am sure you can't understand either but I am in two worlds.
Where are you????? - 8/7/2010 5:35:54 PM
On my job, I regularly council people about their weight and diet as it relates to health and illness. I get many snide remarks such as "easy for you to say". It's every bit as hard to maintain a weight as it is to lose weight. One might even argue that it's harder.
So stop and consider that people do know what you're going through and please don't generalize based on appearance.
- 7/5/2010 3:53:26 PM
My working carreer was OK because I worked for a family owned company and there were a lot of the family members with weight problems too. Now that I am retired I am finally taking the time to figure out why I am an emotional eater and what my trigers are. Life is finally becoming what I always thought it should be. - 7/3/2010 3:53:15 PM
In junior high, I met some friends with whom I'm close to this day. Both of them back in school were really thin & couldn't gain weight, no matter what they did. One of them's still really thin to this day, while the other's gained weight, but she's certainly not obese. With the former, part of it was stress at home as well as the fact that she was & still is active. Even after 2 children, she's still thin, although maybe a little too thin. The other started gaining weight after her first child. I know that part of it was keeping on some of the weight after pregnancy, but, with her, it was also being away from her childhood home (her parents, most especially her mom, was nasty & abusive verbally & emotionally &, upon occasion, physically. She literally kicked & threw my friend out of the house!) & finally being in a calm home. She's in a great place now overall, & I know that her weight gain's partly from that. She's happy & her weight's a sign of that.
As far as understanding the mental hardships of being overweight, neither of these friends really understood it, although they certainly were very good to me & I was thankful for that. They had their own issues, although I never understood why they wanted to gain weight. I do see now what their concerns were. The one friend still doesn't understand what it is to be overweight, but she's still as kind & sweet as ever, & she's still concerned that she doesn't gain weight. However, she's fit & healthy, & that's what she's got going for her.
My other friend does understand a bit now, although she's certainly not obese - just not super thin & just a little bit overweight. Still, she's happy & the healthiest she's been overall in years. - 5/26/2010 9:57:21 PM
Now, as an overweight person I can understand the painful side of it physically and emotionally. I'll be honest though-- there have been times someone with a great/healthy body has walked past me and I've felt a stab of jealousy and judged them for being thin...
It's a 2 way street. - 5/23/2010 10:11:22 PM
Another observation I would make is: Who says you have to be a size 2 or a size 4 to be the right weight? I think our society has made weight more of an issue than it really should be. Back in the '40's, you were considered way too skinny if you were a size 2. They liked women who had "shape" to them. The popular women actually had hips and a butt. Imagine that. I honestly believe that every person was designed to be built differently. For me to wear a size 2 or 4, I would have to have surgery to make my bones smaller. The natural spread of my hip bones just will never allow me to be that size. Yes, I need to lose weight to be a "healthy" weight, but I don't think we should all look anorexic, either. - 5/23/2010 9:54:43 PM
- 5/22/2010 11:20:37 PM
Someone relating to weight issues is all relative to so many things. Some people have kind, loving and supportive people in their lives regardless of their size, others have people who mock them or treat them differently because of their size. Some of us have deep emotional scarring and others are completely fine. People who aren't overweight can relate to certain aspects that they have experienced. Someone who has been picked on for other reasons aside from weight can sympathize with someone who has been picked on for weight. Even someone who was popular can empathize with someone who has been picked on. You can't feel the full effect of the damage or judgment unless you have experienced it yourself though, and even then we all think and feel differently. - 5/21/2010 12:45:22 PM
BUT, I also recognize that other people face a host of problems and issues that I could never relate to. I could never understand the hardship of having a child with autism, the pain one feels while watching their spouse losing their battle with cancer, the desperation of trying to end an addiction to drugs or alcohol, the shame of going from being the "popular girl" in high school to being a single mother shopping at The Salvation Army (as I saw happen to many girls I went to school with).
I think the lesson here is that we all need to learn to treat each other with kindness and compassion, not with judgement and criticism. - 5/21/2010 10:48:16 AM
A wise person once told me, don't compare your inside to anybody else's outside. Your insecurities about your weight should not be compared to that thin, fit person that appears to have all the confidence in the world - you don't know what they are dealing with and it may be something that makes your weight issue look like a paper cut. - 5/19/2010 8:04:29 AM
I mention this based on personal experience. I run at least 5k a day and eat incredibly healthy. I always get comments like 'why did you order a salad, you're so skinny!' and I find it very irritating. It never seems to dawn on people that perhaps the salad is WHY I'm fit. The judging goes both ways! - 5/18/2010 3:38:07 PM
While I've never been overweight in my life, that doesn't mean I haven't struggled. I've worked very hard to maintain my weight (and trust me, I don't have the greatest genes). I understand what it takes to remain a healthy weight so I'm not walking around looking for people to judge.
Everyone has something to work on, myself included. I have very thin friends, who I encourage to exercise to become healthier. But if I spread the same encouragement to overweight friends, many of them become defensive. It's such a taboo subject, and many times its not judgement, it's wanting my friends to be healthy and live active lives.
Do people judge you before they get to know you? Of course. But you have control over whether you do that to other people. And that question rings true not just for weight, but for a lot of things. Do you "judge" or make snap decisions about the skinny blond girl carrying a chihuahua in a bright pink Coach purse? Do you judge the guy in the back of the bus with tattered clothes and a long beard? What about the woman with the big, frizzy hair?
- 5/18/2010 11:48:01 AM
Well said. I too always felt judged, and in a way still do, but now in a good way. Which I guess reinforces that I was judged before. Sadly, I've allowed my appearance to define me as a person. Before weight loss - I had a poor self esteem and image - I didn't like myself at all. I was/am a good mom, friend, daughter, sister, etc. But I didn't feel like I was. I never felt worthy of any good comments people would make to or about me. This healthy lifestyle journey is one of physical AND mental changes, and so far I don't see an end in site. It's an evolution - a metamorphosis of sorts. I'm glad I have my spark friends with me on this journey! - 5/17/2010 9:02:09 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›