Maybe Your Way Isn’t Always the Best Way
I often joke about the negative things motherhood has brought to my life- lack of sleep, no free time, an acceleration of the aging process, etc. The truth is, motherhood has brought an innumerable amount of positive things to my life. In addition to the great things about my kids, becoming a mom has developed a more compassionate and non-judgmental side to my personality that I might not have had otherwise. Instead of being annoyed or just walking past the mom with the screaming baby in the grocery store, I’m much more likely to ask if there’s anything I can do to help. When I see someone with a different parenting style than mine, I try hard to understand and be respectful of the fact that we aren’t all the same, instead of automatically assuming what they are doing is wrong.
I think part of my hesitation to judge others, especially other moms, comes from the fact that my own parenting and lifestyle choices have been judged by family and friends. And honestly, it doesn’t feel good. I had a conversation with my mom the other day regarding the recent Time magazine cover, featuring a mother breastfeeding her 3-year-old. My mom had very strong feelings about it, but my position was more neutral. A decision like that might not be the best thing for me and my child, but I’m not going to judge someone who chooses something different. (By the way, the intention of this blog is not to start a debate about the acceptable amount of time to breastfeed.)
I’ve had others question a variety of decisions I’ve made, from how much weight I gained during my pregnancy to what I feed my kids, to how I discipline them. The interesting thing is that it’s mostly been moms who do it, less out of concern, but more because I’m doing something different than how they’d recommend. I would think that every mom has experienced this at one time or another, so moms should be the most sensitive to this kind of criticism. Yet that doesn’t seem to be the case. My feeling is that unless a child is in danger (which definitely isn’t the case in my situation), most parents know their kids better than anyone else. They are trying to do a good job of raising them and making the decisions they think are best. It’s fine to offer feedback when asked, but be careful about telling someone they aren’t doing something right just because it’s different.
I think this lesson can apply in many aspects of life, not just parenting. Our society tends to judge anyone who is different for whatever reason: because of their size, religion, income level, political views -- the list goes on and on. I know it sounds a little idealistic, but I think it would be nice if we could learn to understand and accept differences instead of always assuming our way is the best way.
What do you think?
I think part of my hesitation to judge others, especially other moms, comes from the fact that my own parenting and lifestyle choices have been judged by family and friends. And honestly, it doesn’t feel good. I had a conversation with my mom the other day regarding the recent Time magazine cover, featuring a mother breastfeeding her 3-year-old. My mom had very strong feelings about it, but my position was more neutral. A decision like that might not be the best thing for me and my child, but I’m not going to judge someone who chooses something different. (By the way, the intention of this blog is not to start a debate about the acceptable amount of time to breastfeed.)
I’ve had others question a variety of decisions I’ve made, from how much weight I gained during my pregnancy to what I feed my kids, to how I discipline them. The interesting thing is that it’s mostly been moms who do it, less out of concern, but more because I’m doing something different than how they’d recommend. I would think that every mom has experienced this at one time or another, so moms should be the most sensitive to this kind of criticism. Yet that doesn’t seem to be the case. My feeling is that unless a child is in danger (which definitely isn’t the case in my situation), most parents know their kids better than anyone else. They are trying to do a good job of raising them and making the decisions they think are best. It’s fine to offer feedback when asked, but be careful about telling someone they aren’t doing something right just because it’s different.
I think this lesson can apply in many aspects of life, not just parenting. Our society tends to judge anyone who is different for whatever reason: because of their size, religion, income level, political views -- the list goes on and on. I know it sounds a little idealistic, but I think it would be nice if we could learn to understand and accept differences instead of always assuming our way is the best way.
What do you think?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > How to Get Your Kids to Drink Water






















.jpg)
Comments
At first, my inner Mom-who-successfully raised-five-kids to adulthood (and Mimaw who's helping to raise a wonderful granddaughter) had ALL kinds of "advice" to dispense... but then I started to REALLY listen.
Their exchanges are clearly heard - a curse of urban city life - but that also makes it clear the adults are very patient with the girl, and are trying to firmly but kindly deal with her. I realized they're coping with issues I never had.
Now, when it's 2am or 4am or whenever, and she starts screaming and yelling in a frantic tantrum - while I still listen to ensure the safety of the situation - I have nothing but sympathy for BOTH the child and adults.
Thanks for the blog - it's a good reminder! : )
- 7/30/2012 3:27:17 AM
On the other hand, many folk who care and would like to help - they are now put off from making any comment, because they get snapped at or bad-mouthed by the person they would like to try to give some positive support to!
Yes it is easy to criticise, where we really have no right even to comment.
But it is also way too easy to react to a question or comment totally inappropriately?
Some learning, thinking, realisation is needed on both sides of the equation. - 7/26/2012 3:52:10 PM
Being critical and judgemental toward others seems to be growing way too common. It's seldom polite, and often loud and confrontational.
Of course, when I was young, I knew everything, and had many strong opinions.
Fortunately, with age comes wisdom, and like many other seniors, I have developed extreme open-mindedness!
All you parents, just keep doing what you feel is best...it probably is ! - 7/26/2012 11:27:00 AM
And--a bit more on topic--it's very rare that I'll attempt to intervene in a family's dynamics. When I was a mandated reporter, I reported two cases of child abuse. Other than that, in the last 21+ years, I confronted one mother when she lost control in a restaurant and was slapping her very young daughter's hand repeatedly--not swats, but hard and for such long time that she didn't seem inclined to ever stop.
All in all, I think it's hard enough to raise one's own child, much less try to raise everyone else's.
Also, despite the risk of West Nile virus, I'd be more concerned about a totally covered child getting vitamin D deficiency than an infected insect. However, knowing how uncomfortable insect bites are, I'd be inclined to use a natural insect repellent. Either way, though, I'd be most likely to assume the parent weighed the option and made what they thought was the best decision for their child. - 7/25/2012 3:24:19 PM
I'm learning to just keep my mouth shut. I'm not the one walking in either of their shoes, so I can only speak on what I think would work for me.
Believe me--keeping quiet is WAY harder than expressing an opinion or passing judgement! - 7/25/2012 3:08:32 PM
When I raised my own children, breastfeeding was not in "style" but I did it anyway. Now this method is in vogue.
Every mom should parent her way--- hopefully the children will learn to be civilized and respectful. (smile) - 7/25/2012 12:28:40 PM
I'm just glad that my kids are bringing my grandchildren perfectly. My daughter in law does everything right and my grandkids are turning out perfect. - 7/25/2012 12:08:34 PM
I had a mpother who had a kid who was misbehaving, he was mad he wasn't gettinf what he wanted, she did tell him no, he can't have it. He got mad, threw a temper tantum then smacked her butt. I did not appreciated seeing that. I was in the middle of ringing through her order (I'm a cashier for a convience store). It would have been nice if she pulled him off to the side to punsih him (I would have cancelled the order and go from there to see how to proceed with her items), but she just took it, paid and left. The person behind also thought the same as me, but we knew we weren't that parent and don't have a right to comment on how she parents, we don't know the whole story as to why he did that. - 7/25/2012 10:53:28 AM
People are always going to judge and discriminate. They're not terrible for doing so; it's a natural response to the life around them. - 7/25/2012 9:03:54 AM
It can be somewhat rude to interfere with others' parenting skills, especially when there's no evidence or no net gain in doing so or when the advice giver is really just using the opportunity to feel superior to another parent; however, when we perceive danger, it may be better safe than sorry. How many times have we seen the videos on TV with a fake child abduction and everyone just walks by? If it takes a village to raise a child, it could certainly be helpful to hear more ideas. In the end, it's still our own responsibility to choose the right thing and live with the consequences of our choices. It would be great if we lived in a world where people trusted each other and had each other's best interests at heart... - 7/25/2012 1:46:01 AM
Like this one time a man criticized how I parent (b/c I didn't give my daughter "a good whooping" when she pinched me in public) and compared how well his children behave. Of course the person apologized when I explained to him that my daughter is mentally handicapped and can't even talk.
Some people should just learn to shut up. - 7/24/2012 8:41:12 PM
When (most) women see a single mother, a lot of judgement and criticism comes into play. Who are we to judge a situation, when we don't know the story. - 7/24/2012 7:27:37 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›