If More Americans are Exercising, Why Aren't We Losing Weight?
After I had my second child, I lost most of the pregnancy weight pretty quickly. I was active throughout the nine months and started back into my regular routine soon after birth. I even started training for another marathon when my son was 7 months old. But I had this pesky 5-10 pounds that just wouldn't go away. I assumed it was just because I was nursing, but I stopped when my son turned one and those pounds still hung on. I couldn't understand it; I was extremely active and ate a (generally) healthy diet. Was I destined to keep those extra pounds forever?
Even though I heard it all the time (from myself and other members) on the SparkPeople Message Boards, I never thought this advice applied to me: "You can't out-train a bad diet." In general, I eat 4-5 servings of fruits and vegetables a day, whole grains, and try to follow the principles of a healthy diet. But I was also eating a small handful of M&M's here-and-there throughout the day, I could easily go through a box of Nilla wafers (one of my favorites) in a couple of days, and I'd bring home cookies or some other kind of treat far too often. I always felt like it was my reward for a hard run or a really good workout. I was sure I was burning tons of calories, so I should be able to eat a few extra, right? In reality, it wasn't just a few extra, it was many extra. And those treats were the reason I couldn't lose the last of the weight.
A new survey from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that obesity rates remain around 28%, which is the same as the data from 2008. The good news is that in 2009, 34.7% of Americans claimed they engage in regular leisure physical activity, up from 31.9% in 2008. If people are more active, why aren't less of us obese? There could be a number of reasons, but one of my guesses is that even though we're moving more, we're still eating too much.
Once I started being very conscious of my diet and cutting out a lot of the extra sugar, I lost those last few pounds pretty easily. My diet is far from perfect, and I still enjoy the foods I love. I just try to eat them in moderation. For example, I'll measure out one serving of Nilla wafers instead of eating half of the box in one sitting. And I try not to use food as my reward for a good workout. My reward is the feeling of accomplishment I have after I know I've pushed myself and met the challenge.
Have you ever used exercise as an excuse to eat more than you should? In your experience, how important is diet versus exercise when it comes to weight loss?
Even though I heard it all the time (from myself and other members) on the SparkPeople Message Boards, I never thought this advice applied to me: "You can't out-train a bad diet." In general, I eat 4-5 servings of fruits and vegetables a day, whole grains, and try to follow the principles of a healthy diet. But I was also eating a small handful of M&M's here-and-there throughout the day, I could easily go through a box of Nilla wafers (one of my favorites) in a couple of days, and I'd bring home cookies or some other kind of treat far too often. I always felt like it was my reward for a hard run or a really good workout. I was sure I was burning tons of calories, so I should be able to eat a few extra, right? In reality, it wasn't just a few extra, it was many extra. And those treats were the reason I couldn't lose the last of the weight.
A new survey from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that obesity rates remain around 28%, which is the same as the data from 2008. The good news is that in 2009, 34.7% of Americans claimed they engage in regular leisure physical activity, up from 31.9% in 2008. If people are more active, why aren't less of us obese? There could be a number of reasons, but one of my guesses is that even though we're moving more, we're still eating too much.
Once I started being very conscious of my diet and cutting out a lot of the extra sugar, I lost those last few pounds pretty easily. My diet is far from perfect, and I still enjoy the foods I love. I just try to eat them in moderation. For example, I'll measure out one serving of Nilla wafers instead of eating half of the box in one sitting. And I try not to use food as my reward for a good workout. My reward is the feeling of accomplishment I have after I know I've pushed myself and met the challenge.
Have you ever used exercise as an excuse to eat more than you should? In your experience, how important is diet versus exercise when it comes to weight loss?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > 12 Delicious Ways to Use Blueberries









.jpg)













Comments
- 7/5/2010 11:39:56 AM
Writing down everything I eat has made me painfully aware of how much I was shoveling into my mouth without even thinking about it. I have been a regular gym-goer for years, and there's not question, that exercise alone will not get the weight off, even though it has been good for my stamina, balance, and flexibility, and of course, those weight-bearing exercises help counter osteoporosis.
Many of the comments here have been excellent too. Pre-packaged foods are SO tempting for those of us with busy lives (and that's most of us). I've learned to be a nutrition label reader, and am still shocked to see the values on some seemingly healthy products.
I hadn't thought about the psychological trick we play on ourselves by thinking we can eat because we went to the gym. I'll be more aware of that one from now on. - 7/1/2010 10:45:43 AM
My son and I even joke about it. The chips/candy/pop aisle we call the Staples Aisle. - 6/30/2010 4:36:15 PM
Thanks for the article. - 6/30/2010 4:18:57 PM
Tracking the food and making myself face the calories is my key strategy. When I do this right, I know that working out will not erase an extra 600 cals in snacks or high cal food in a day. So I have to live with the consequences of some bad choices that day, and I don't expect to lose any weight.
However, I also track my exercise calories and do this on the conservative side. So, I balance the calories in and calories spent consciously. By planning this way, I can have a treat and not totally blow my calories.
The general rationalization: "well, I walked today so I can eat what I want" doesn't cut it for me anymore. No one is perfect however. We err because we're human. - 6/30/2010 1:25:30 PM
It makes sense too that with all the doctor shows, Oprah and the like, I think that people are over-estimating how active they really are. We are told that walking at a steady pace for 10 minutes counts as exercise, when the reality is that you gotta work up a sweat! - 6/30/2010 12:14:32 PM
IMO, anyway, it is pretty simple and basic and not a big mystery.
I also think most people overestimate how many calories they burn in exercise and underestimate how many calories they eat. - 6/30/2010 11:45:12 AM
Thank you for sharing this blog! - 6/30/2010 11:43:54 AM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›