Do Working Moms Have Unhealthy Kids?
I like to think that overall, I'm a good mom. Some days are better than others, but in general, I try to provide a good example for my kids. We eat healthy, engage in physical activity like playing on the swing set or going to the park, they don't watch TV, etc. Another way I think I'm a good example is by showing them that you can be a good mom and have a career at the same time--if that's something you want. But is that a bad choice? A new British study concludes that children whose mothers work are less likely to eat healthy or exercise.
My mom always worked part-time when I was growing up. It wasn't because she had to (lucky for her), but because she wanted to. She used to tell me that someday I'd understand, and when I had children, I did. I love my job wanted to continue working, so I reduced my hours to part-time. I'm lucky that I had the financial stability to make that choice. So maybe my kids are an exception to the average children in this study, but I just find the results hard to believe.
The study, published in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health looked at the diet and exercise habits of children ages 9 months to 5 years. "Regardless of ethnicity, maternal education or job level, children whose mothers worked part or full time were less likely to eat fruits or vegetables at meals or as snacks," according to the study. Children whose mothers worked also watched more TV, got less physical activity and drank more sugary beverages.
The study said that "Children whose mothers were employed were more likely to have poor dietary habits, engage in more sedentary activity and be driven to school than children whose mothers had never been employed." The researchers also concluded that flexible work arrangements did not have a positive affect on developing healthy behaviors in children. I think my children can be just as healthy as a child whose mother has chosen to stay at home. I provide good examples while I'm home, and when I'm not, their grandparents (who watch them) understand my wishes and provide the same examples for me.
What do you think? Do you agree with the results of the study? Why or why not?
My mom always worked part-time when I was growing up. It wasn't because she had to (lucky for her), but because she wanted to. She used to tell me that someday I'd understand, and when I had children, I did. I love my job wanted to continue working, so I reduced my hours to part-time. I'm lucky that I had the financial stability to make that choice. So maybe my kids are an exception to the average children in this study, but I just find the results hard to believe.
The study said that "Children whose mothers were employed were more likely to have poor dietary habits, engage in more sedentary activity and be driven to school than children whose mothers had never been employed." The researchers also concluded that flexible work arrangements did not have a positive affect on developing healthy behaviors in children. I think my children can be just as healthy as a child whose mother has chosen to stay at home. I provide good examples while I'm home, and when I'm not, their grandparents (who watch them) understand my wishes and provide the same examples for me.
What do you think? Do you agree with the results of the study? Why or why not?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |























Comments
very healthy. He is physically active in all sports, plays the drum, can fix a computer, create a great family video and has more friend than one could imagine. Although not perfect, he allowed me to have a gratifying career, a wonderful marriage and a whole life. He was put first, as a gift from God yet working was important to my mental health allowing me to be a better mother.
I believe, each situation is different and you have to know yourself, know your child and go with what is best. I was away a great deal when he was small...retired early by choice in his teens and to be honest I felt he needed me more then...because emotional maturity required a closer hand than physical maturing! - 3/22/2012 10:59:16 PM
Clint
www.thecarepost.com - 1/10/2011 10:15:08 PM
So, please stop the guilt inducing stereo type comments!!!!
Until we are doing studies about how working dads or single dads are screwing up thier kids, leave moms alone! - 1/12/2010 1:29:44 PM
I still push on, and do my best, even though I could be doing WAY better! - 10/26/2009 11:39:46 AM
My mom was a working mom, and was going to school full time during part of that. I grew up making my own meals, throwing together my own school lunches, and even forging my own late excuse notices. I did not learn how to integrate good foods into my diet from my parents.
My point is, remember that those of us on this site are the ones who know that we can balance our lives better. The study shows "less likely", not that the kids of all working moms eat poorly. Don't take offense. Take note, and be grateful that you are in a position to be on the other side of those results. - 10/22/2009 4:28:45 PM
And it can be a fun meal without it being a "Lunchables". They are expensive and have little nutrition.
Crustless peanut butter and jelly sandwiches? Puhleeze!
Robyn - 10/22/2009 4:19:02 PM
Perhaps rather than doing studies that add to the argument of which type of mom is a better mom, the various experts might put effort into helping all moms obtain the required knowledge and resources to help children be healthy. - 10/21/2009 11:10:07 AM
My mom was working and I grew up to be an obese child. However it had nothing to do with the fact that she was working etc etc ( according to this study)
I was overfed as a child both by my grand mother ( who was watching me) and by my mom when she got home. Having no idea about calorie intakes and being tom-boyish ( not too much into the girly stuff or looks etc), I grew up to be an obese child ( often referred to as a healthy one).
However, I think that working moms can definitely provide equal amount of care to their kids as others. Packing healthy lunches to kids alone is not going to make them not eat junk foods when they are out at school. More awareness at an early age ( something that I did not get), not overfeeding kids (looking thin doesnt mean not healthy) and encouraging sports/outdoor activities to kids will definitely help them in the long run. This can be achieved by both working or stay at home moms.
- 10/20/2009 8:42:03 PM
Stay home mom doesn't neccessarily equal a "good" mom... I don't even have to conduct a study to make the statment that among crack addicted moms, the majority are stay home moms. How much health food do you think those families are eating?
It's time to put an end to bashing working moms...especially single moms. - 10/20/2009 7:22:48 PM
If you have good healthy eating habits your kids will too. No doubt, if you eat what you're feeding your kids, then your diet is either just as healthy, or no better than their's. - 10/20/2009 4:59:09 PM
She said she cooked all day for all her customers, why did she want to come home and cook for us?! Can you believe that? We would eat the weirdest concoctions for sandwiches, like, mustard and onion sandwiches or mayonaisse,
aka, Miracle Whip on bread. We'd eat cold hot dogs. Sometimes I'd get really brave and one time I tried to cook rice, we were so hungry. I had to use 6 saucepans of varying sizes to accomodate all the rice I put in that first pan. What a fiasco. Another time I tried to make french fries, set the kitchen on fire. Thank God my dad hadn't left the yard, he was in a car heading out the driveway when
he saw the flames shoot up the kitchen window. If our mom had taken the time to get up from the couch and teach me how to cook, things would have gone more
smoothly. The result of all this is that all of her kids have never, ever eaten healthy meals. The two girls are overweight, one of our brothers was morbidly obese, he died last year from a very bad heart and one brother is so underweight because he didn't like anything but, spanish rice and fish sticks. Hope your diet is better than ours was. And, now we girls struggle to lose weight and find it a difficult battle. One of the reasons we are here! - 10/20/2009 3:20:31 PM
I question the validity of the study. Is it randomized or a retrospective review? I am sure there are many confounding variables that make me question its validity.
Bottom line: SAHM moms work too, but it is all about the QUALITY of the time you spend with your kids, not QUANTITY. I am tired of the perception that working mothers ignore their kids! - 10/20/2009 3:10:37 PM
My ex step mother stayed at home, and prepared only Hamburger Helper (without draining the grease), and I never saw a vegetable in her kitchen. She fed her children cheeseburgers every day, along with fried french fries and regular pop. TV was the babysitter.
My mom worked, but she did her best to feed me right. Even if she couldn't afford fresh fruits and veggies, she would cook dinner and not take me to a fast food place. She had 2 jobs sometimes, and our utilities were always being shut off. At least she spent all the time she could with me, fed me better things than Hamburger Helper, and monitored how much TV I watched.
I think it has to do with the mom.
And where are the dads in these situations?
- 10/20/2009 2:31:59 PM
- 10/20/2009 1:05:17 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›